Find something (an idea, a claim, an argument, etc.) in Bulman Ch 1 to disagree with. Explain what it is and shy you disagree with it. Note: If you absolutely can’t find something to disagree with, feel free to write about that situation (why you can’t disagree) or simply discuss something that you found interesting in Ch. 1.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
August 24…Popculture
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring ...
-
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring ...
-
Postman has some interesting ideas about what kinds of skills we need to learn in school. Looking back, do you think you were ever taught ho...
-
What other classes have you had in which individualism was discussed? How was it talked about? Is it seen largely as a good thing or a bad t...
Irelyn here-
ReplyDeleteBulman basically argues that high school movies just spoon-feed us "cultural myths" so we blindly accept basic, middle-class American values. Honestly, I totally disagree with this because it treats teen audiences like we're just passive zombies who absorb whatever's on screen without actually thinking or making our own judgments. For example, movies like Mean Girls or Clueless, on the surface they look like standard, shallow popular-girl tropes, but my generation (Gen Z) actually watches them as sharp satires that are literally making fun of consumerism, cliquey high school drama, and superficial wealth. This completely goes against Bulman's whole point. Viewers like me aren't just buying into the "myth"; we're using these exact movies to roast and criticize the high school social structures he thinks the films are trying to protect.
Hi! Elizabeth here!
ReplyDeleteBulman says that Hollywood twists and shapes movies so that they give us a more dramatic effect but that there are still truths to them. I find this interesting because he is saying that we can still learn from them even though they are made to be fictional and not realistic. I think there is some truth to this because we can believe the general concept but not the details because they could be twisted to make it more dramatic.
Alexa here!
ReplyDeleteSomething I found interesting in the chapter I read about films and Hollywood is how films were described and perceived.I don't think I can disagree with anything in this article because this is the first time I have seen this side of how people see films and how they can be used. Films seem to have a big impact on culture and how people see culture through films. Films also tend to have a big impact with research and the overall pattern of the themes in movies. Movies with high schools in them or having their main focus be about high school or high school students is able to give people insight with how it is similar to the world we live in today and the difference and why they made it seem so much more exciting then it is in real life.
Dylan here: One point I found extremely interesting was the line “Films teach us who we are as much as they reflect who we are” from page 3. While I could not find much to disagree with, I thought this line in particular was a good overall reflection of the point Bulman was trying to make in this section. Everything about society can be symbolic, especially when it comes to the arts. People are subconsciously driven by the cultures surrounding them and often, inspiration strikes because of it. Movie analyses are so fascinating because there are often way more layers to every line, shot, and any other choice that could have been made; it’s all done with intention to show something about the plot or the focused characters. This can then reveal what the film is saying about the culture it surrounds, whether it is a modern high school or a historical event 100 years ago. It’s sort of a paradoxical take that films teach us by imitating who we already are, but it is one I definitely agree with, especially because specific cultural traits can be so invisible to someone who sees it as the norm. Sometimes all it takes is someone holding up a (metaphorical) mirror to reveal the underlying realities, myths, and how we’ve changed over time.
ReplyDeleteOne thing I found myself disagreeing with in Bulman Chapter 1 was the idea that movies and TV shows can have such a strong influence on how people see high school. I understand that the media can affect how we think about certain things, but I don't think it completely shapes our view of what high school is supposed to be like. I think everyone has different experiences, so even if someone watches a lot of movies about high school, they can still realize that real life is not always like what they see in TV. For example, a lot of high school movies make it seem like popularity, dating, drama, and fitting in are the most important parts of school. While those things can definently happen, I don't think they represent everyone's experience. Some people might be more focused on their grades, family, sports, jobs, or their own personal goals. I think Bulman makes a good point about how media can create certain expectations, but I disagree with the idea that people will automatically believe those expectations. Personally, I think most people can tell the difference between entertainment and real life, even if the media sometimes influences what we expect. - Noura
ReplyDeleteMaria M
ReplyDeleteAs I was reading Bulman Chapter he mentions how films influence how we see the world. I agree with the fact that he brings up that we may not agree or accept every message shown. He further elaborates on how we are able integrate the main point or lesson into our lives and society. Bulman says, "Film teaches us who we are as much as they reflect who we are." I think it is important to note that films are a reflection of us, because many films do portray us. However, I would have to disagree a little about how film teaches us who we are, while it may be fitting for protagonist and antagonist, some film do not necessarily teach us who we are sometimes, which why I like that he brought up that we do not have to accept or agree with anything shown.
One thing that I agree with and disagree with is when Bulman says that he believes that films influence how we see the world. I agree with it partly because when we were kids, we didn’t know how to make the distinction between reality and films. I think that certain shows and movies shaped the way we perceived certain things like gender roles. Now that we are adults, we are able to make that distinction, and we do not accept everything that we see, as Bulman says on page 3, “ We do not necessarily accept every message we receive without questioning it.”
ReplyDeleteOne of the ideas I disagreed in Chapter 1 is Bulman’s idea that popular movies bring people together because everyone can enjoy the same movies. He explains that watching popular culture can give people a shared experience and help connect members of society. I do agree he has a point, but I do not think watching the same movie automatically brings people closer. People can watch the same movie and have completely different opinions about it. Some people might like it while others might not like it at all. I think people are more likely to connect through movies when they actually talk about them and share similar interests. Just because a movie is popular does not mean everyone feels connected to it. - Tiffany T
ReplyDeleteChloe Here!!
ReplyDeleteI would say that I agree and disagree with Bulman's idea of popular movies. I don't necessarily agree with the fact that film teaches us who we are, I think it can help us understand a character if one relates to them but it does not define us. Movies and film are exaggerated for dramatic effect, while society may reflect it, it is not reality. On the other hand I would agree when Bulman states that "We do not Necessarily accept every message we receive without questioning it"(pg3). Everything should be questioned and not taken at face value, there are things that have hidden meaning and would be nothing without someone questioning it and asking "Why".
Alexis here-- I disagree with his claim on page 2 that film studies generally does not delve deeper than interpreting the message behind each film. The critiques and studies Bulman read when he was writing this book (which he later says he began in 2000, so there has definitely been a cultural shift in the study of films since then) may have been shallow, but from my experience, there are a multitude of other lenses with which to interrogate a film's themes, claims, imagery, and relevance in society. Intentionally or not, this made me think that Bulman sees studying film as an art as a lesser medium for interpreting pop culture, even though his book intends to do exactly that.
ReplyDeleteI feel like the way Bulman treats movies at some points in the chapter is more objectifying and it seems like he wants to treat movies as if they're something that can be "measured," when that's simply anything but the case. Films are one of the most important genres of art. Art will always be unpredictable, with the underlying meaning behind it being something that can be interpreted differently by anyone and everyone. And while Bulman does seem to gloss over this claim, he mainly treats it as a form of "consumption" and "production," while films are an unchanging part of art that cannot be binded to such one-dimensional ideas that are a form of economy rather than societal and/or cultural. - Jared M
ReplyDeleteIn the reading Bulman says that films have truths and they reflect culture which I agree but also disagree with. Sometimes in films they exaggerate the truth but it does have a reflection of the truth. Obviously not everything that happens in the movies happens in real life but I think sometimes they have the general idea just maybe twisted a little bit to add more plot for the film. Films can also reflect what's happening in the world right now. For example shows and movies since 2020 reference covid, ICE and make jokes about current politicians. So I do agree that films can have truths and reflect culture but are just exaggerated and fibbed a little while the general idea is truthful. - Lucy Belyea
ReplyDeleteThroughout reading this article, I find it interesting that Bulman uses films as a tool to analyze culture. However, as a film major student, I do not think the author is rigorous enough in the field of film. "Hollywood films tend to convey the sensibilities of the American middle class: individualism…" Bulman's opinion on Hollywood films is just my opinion on this chapter. I think the concept of "movie" that the author discusses is mainly based on American mainstream films and excludes American independent films, which is a rather narrow definition.
ReplyDelete"Generally speaking, sociology is the study of social reality, not fantasy." However, many films are not fantasy; they are quite realistic. In fact, the director of Parasite, Bong Joon-ho, even had a degree in sociology before he became a director.
I agree with most of Bulman’s analysis, and it articulated a lot of what I have witnessed in pop culture and how it informs my real-life interactions. However, I think his evaluation that the throughline throughout high school movies being individualism is the most interesting. I think this aspect of the high school movie holds a mirror up to the ideals of middle-class America. The archetype of the ambitious underdog or outsider succeeding is ever present in American culture. This raises the question: without these movies perpetuating these messages, would we still value individualism as much today? In a world where we value social capital more than ever, whether through social media, relationships, or in the workplace, if not for these stories, would we still hold individualism as highly as we do today?
ReplyDeleteOne point from Bulman Ch. 1 that I want to critique is the impact of film expectations on real teen behavior. By constantly feeding audiences exaggerated and negative ideas about how adolescents act, Hollywood sets a toxic baseline. Instead of just reflecting reality, these movies create unfair expectations for how adults view teens and how teens feel pressured to act. Adolescence is already a challenging transitional period, and perpetuating these negative stereotypes only makes that growth harder.
ReplyDeleteGrace Rasch-
ReplyDeleteI found it interesting how movies don’t reflect reality but rather the cultures, influences, ideas, and standards of those who drive the film industry with the intention of pleasing the public eye. Often when watching high school movies, whether on my own or with friends, we are quick to notice a disconnect between the reality of the social and educational environment in high school as opposed to how it is portrayed online. Such movies influenced us at a younger age, preparing us for a high school experience that didn’t exist. It makes me wonder whether the production of films is influenced more by their need to cater to a particular audience or if film more often influences the audience.
Hi Yulissa here!
ReplyDeleteI disagree with Bulman when he categorized a variety of American teen and high school films to tropes that we would see often in films and ideological messages hinting towards the educational system. Many people have different views on how highschool is based on their experiences. Bulman would show that teens were usually crazy and did not show respect for the teachers. As for the teachers, they were shown as not caring and being there just as a babysitter. When watching these films it doesn’t really feel like a school and it is hard to find relation in it for the viewers. I believe they create this view points just for entertainment and a certain audience and not because it is a view of the real world.
Xavier here!
ReplyDeleteOne of the points which I agree and disagree with is the position taken by Bulman that films impact our perception of the world. I agree with this argument partly in the sense that when we were kids, we could not always tell apart what we see in films from what was really realistic. Certain films and TV shows may have played a part in shaping our views about things such as gender roles and societal norms. But as grownups, we now know how to separate the two. In addition, we tend to be critical about the messages shown to us, unlike when we were young when we easily accepted things for granted. As Bulman says on page 3, “We do not necessarily accept every message we receive without questioning it.”
Bulman makes a lot of excellent points about the influence of film and how it shows schools, however i feel that Bulmans makes a lot of generalized statements about this genre and discusses the issues he brings up as fact. Bulman makes great points in this article but i feel like he generalizes the ideas from a lot of these films and that ultimately discredits films that aim to strive away from these ideals. I feel that Bulman has good intentions with this article but i think he discredits the ability of audiences ability to analyze these films past surface level. He critiques these films for being simple and perpetuating unrealistic expectations for school for through his analysis looks at films through one lens and doesn't seem to attempt to look at it from more than one view.
ReplyDeleteI think something I disagree with Bulman on is that the films conceptions of schooling correlate strongly even directly almost to average American conceptions of schooling... I will first say I agree with the fact that the films both reflect and shape our society (to an extent). But I think he gives too much credit to Americans. I'm guilty of it too, but Americans are a lot more pessimistic and unconcerned to actually think the savior or hero tropes work. Yes, they make you feel good, but they don't actually do anything. And I think that speaks less to the general people of our country and more to executives, systems, producers, and who ever else is trying to get the most money and profit they can. Like when we watched Girl Meets World's Feminism episode, I think everyone understood how lukewarm it was and that it was like deserving of a cookie, but when you are on a children's network and have to pander to both advertisers and the general public, you're messages can't be radical by any means. I think Bulman should've paid more attention/ gone deeper into the systemic issues present in films and steered towards the actual producers and companies responsible for making and funding the films. That I think gives a lot more info as to what our society is saying and valuing than trying to say that we all largely feel the same way these movies say we do. - Taylor
ReplyDeleteI definitely think Bulman has an interesting perspective on Highschool films but as others have said i do feel people are going to have different feelings and reactions and opinions on high school compared to their own experiences. And while I do think some of them are cliche but some of them also have deeper themes and meanings that cant be categorized in the game group of the cliche films. -Cylie Ortiz
ReplyDeleteI did not fully disagree with any of Bulman's ideas. Thinking back on all the school centered films I have watched, I could see where he is coming from with each of his points and ideas. But, I did find it interesting how seemingly easy it was for Bulman to create a system and categorize the movies. When I first watched the movies that he mentioned I thought they were all unique in their own way, but Bulman's criteria put a lot of them into perspective for me. Now I realize that most of these films weren't as revolutionary as I thought, and instead had a lot of the same patterns. With these defined categories, I also found myself grouping these films and thinking about them in ways I never had before.
ReplyDelete