Find something recent from the news about book banning/censorship. You can relate it to the New Kid situation or feel free to write about anything you want to think about/discuss related to the topic.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
August 24…Popculture
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring ...
-
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring ...
-
Postman has some interesting ideas about what kinds of skills we need to learn in school. Looking back, do you think you were ever taught ho...
-
What other classes have you had in which individualism was discussed? How was it talked about? Is it seen largely as a good thing or a bad t...
irelyn- Recent news shows that U.S. public school book bans hit an all-time high of nearly 12,000 instances (11,982) during the 2025–2026 school year, according to a major October 2026 report from Pen America. One of the most striking new developments in the data is how school districts are using artificial intelligence to audit library shelves, alongside a massive surge in removals of graphic novels and manga. This current wave connects directly to the controversy surrounding Jerry Craft's Newbery-winning graphic novel, New Kid, which became an early flashpoint in modern school censorship debates.
ReplyDeleteElizabeth - There were a ton of books banned last school year. I was doing research, and some of the banned books were Jane Eyre, Romeo and Juliet, and Manga. Manga is a graphic novel, just like New Kid, and it was banned for the graphic panels being taken out of context with depictions of violence, gender identity, and others. These books are deemed inappropriate or explicit. New Kid was also banned not for the same reasons as manga, but for being racist and was deemed harmful. But the people banning the books are taking the books as a whole out of context and judging one panel for the whole book.
ReplyDeleteDylan here: According to the American Library Association, the Office of Intellectual Freedom 4,235 different titles were targeted for censorship in 2025, the second highest ever in ALA documented history. Of those, 39% involve the lives of LGBTQ+ people and people of color, and 92% of challenges were initiated by government officials and decision makers. It is appalling that government officials, the people who run our states and country, are trying so hard to censor and remove novels involving historically extremely oppressed groups from the shelves so that younger generations cannot access them to learn. Empathy is built on putting yourself in the shoes of others and being able to see perspectives different from yours, and if no one can learn to empathize, we will just become more divided as a country.
ReplyDeleteIn recent news about book bannings, nearly 22,810 have been recorded in U.S public schools since PEN America began tracking them in July 2021 and nearly 7,000 book bannings were documented in U.S public schools during 2024-2025. Many of these book bannings had a pattern of race, LGBTQ+, and Indigenous voices. It's unnecessary for these books to be banned when the purpose of these books are to educate students and people in the world. Removing these books that educate and make people think, it creates some sort of disconnection from history and the world around us. We wouldn't be able to expand our minds to see the perspectives of others and learn about ourselves as an individual. - Tiffany
ReplyDeleteThe free speech center talks about book banning and how children literature is the main target. A lot of the causes for book banning is due to the content within the book making it seem like the book is trying to teach the kids a different thing or steer their mindset a different way. If a book has one small section of nudity or mentioning something inappropriate, it has to get banned immediately because kids are not allowed to read about explicit topics. I think that even if books mention something that's explicit but it's so small and it still gets banned, I don't think people are worrying about the right things being displayed in schools. We have to learn FLE in 4th grade and that talks about explicit things so I find it crazy how one small picture of nudity or mentioning something inappropriate in a book is enough to get it banned. If schools are so worried about what kids will have access to in the school library and whether or not it's appropriate then maybe we should hold off on explicit topics such as FLE since adults think that students will steer their thinking a certain way or simply ask questions. I think that what is displayed in a book versus what adults teach students are two different things and adults have the control of teaching their students certain things, authors make their books for anyone and everyone and that should not be an issue.
ReplyDelete-Alexa
Maria M
ReplyDeleteIn Ireland, over 12,000 historical books were banned. This was because they were considered as either “indecent, obscene, or advocating unnatural practices”. For decades they were kept out of people’s reach. However, recently the repeal of older censorship is relocating the books to become more and used for historical research. I find it interesting how books written by supposedly great writers were banned especially Nobel Prize winners. With that, basic health/wellness and biology books were banned because they were deemed as too obscene. Where do we draw the line on what is considered appropriate/educational now a days?
Lately, school districts around the nation have been increasing their use of AI book banning. It got bigger in October this year. And its bad (not only because of AI use), but AI “hallucinates” and takes things completely out of context and oftentimes it’ll flag books simply because another district or “admin” type banned them which creates a big snowball effect. - Taylor
ReplyDeleteAlexis- According to the article I have linked at the bottom, in 2025 my hometown of Virginia Beach banned 16 new books from its public school libraries. Some of the banned books were titles I had heard arguments about a few years ago when I was still in VBCPS, but some are new to being banned (even if the titles themselves are not knew to being published). It's always a shame to see so many books taken out of schools, especially when they are written to be targeted towards YA/teenage audiences. It's especially disconcerting to see so many nonfiction books on biology, growing up, and psychology being banned, since my personal experience of the health classes given to students in VB proves it was incredibly lacking in useful, factual information. It is my opinion that, generally speaking, any book written (for example) for the audience of a high school student should be available to any high school student, regardless of the political climate of their city or the opinions of their parents.
ReplyDeleteThe article I am referencing: https://cardinalnews.org/2025/07/15/223-book-titles-pulled-from-school-library-shelves-in-virginia-but-75-were-in-just-five-places/
I was reading up on books that were banned in Virginia such as Gender Queer- A Memoir, Fahrenheit 451, 1984 and Catcher in the Rye. I do not agree with book banning I think it's hard to find a situation where everyone is happy but I don't think it should be allowed to take books away from everyone. If parents don't want their kids reading certain books that should be an in household conversation and other students shouldn't be restricted based on others beliefs. I think it's cruel to take books and education from students. Censorship may be another conversation when talking about like smut. I don't think every grade should have access to 50 Shades of Grey but once students get to a certain age I don't think its the school boards place to tell students what they can and cannot read. The school librarians aren't handing the students inappropriate books but they are giving them the chance to explore and read on their own. - Lucy B.
ReplyDeletesam- I wanted to research what the book banning situation was in India because I am from there. To my surprise India has the highest rate of banned books. Books banned in India are most commonly restricted to prevent religious offense, communal violence, and threats to national security. For example, they were the first to ban The Satanic Verses. This is a magical realist novel by Salman Rushdie about two Indian expatriates in London who survive a plane explosion and take on the traits of an angel and a devil. It was banned across dozens of countries for blasphemy and inciting religious unrest. I feel it was cool to see the differences in what is banned in America v.s. India. I still feel books shouldn't be banned even if they talk about a dangerous idea. I think people should be educated enough to be able to critically think on their own to be able to decide what's right and wrong instead of banning things.
ReplyDeleteIn my hometown, there have been efforts to ban books not only in school libraries but also in public libraries since the book-banning craze began in the early 2020s. Recently, King William County school libraries have required a parental form to be filled out to allow students to check out books that contain any form of violence, queer characters, or include any material that could be seen as "offensive," and to further remove any widely contested books. Personally, my little sister had to bring a form home so she could check out a Sailor Moon book from her eighth-grade library; I had also asked her to look for New Kid in the school library for this class, only to find out it was unavailable. In mid 2025, our county library was shut down and removed from the Pamunkey Regional Library System, limiting access to information and resources in my community. Once it reopened earlier this year, they implemented a form of book restriction where they will ID people wanting to check out books deemed more objectionable.
ReplyDeleteOne thing that stood out to me is how book banning is still happening in schools and libraries across the country. I think it is unfair that students are losing access to books just because some people disagree with their topics. Books allow students to learn about different experiences and perspectives, and banning them limits what students get to read and understand. - Noura
ReplyDeleteYulissa here,
ReplyDeleteI read an article about how the American Library Association reported that 4,235 different book titles were a target in 2025, making it the second highest number ever recorded. Most of these books discuss topics such as race, LGBTQ+ experiences, and identity. This connects to New Kid because the book explores racism, stereotypes, and the challenges of fitting in. I think it is important for students to have access to books like these because they help us understand experiences different from our own. Even if a book discusses uncomfortable topics, that doesn't mean students should be prevented from reading it. Books allow people to learn, ask questions, and see the world from different perspectives. I believe students should have the opportunity to think for themselves rather than have certain stories hidden from them.
Chloe Here!
ReplyDeleteSomething I've seen as a common denominator around book banning is that books in general aren't inherently bad, but instead are books that deal with gender, race, religion, or expression. It is unfair to students who want to learn and to express a different perspective that they themselves do not live. The overall banning of books is unnecessary and is done for selfish reasons, mainly by people who do not believe in what the books contain, this leads to others who do believe not having the books that they need to understand.
When I was in 11th grade, I had a literature class where we read a lot of heavy, unfiltered stories which included The Crucible, A Streetcar Named Desire, and Desiree's Baby. I vividly remember this class and the stories we read years later, more specifically, the story "Desiree's Baby" has stuck with me because of how deeply tragic and unsettling it is. It is set during slavery in Louisiana, the story follows a woman named Desiree who has no idea who her parents are and her husband, Armand, kicks her and their newborn son out after the baby begins showing mixed race features. Knowing that being labeled non white in a slave society strips them of all protection, freedom, and standing, Desiree ends up walking into the bayou with her baby and ends up drowning herself with the baby, only for Armand to discover weeks later in an old letter from his mother that he was actually the one with black ancestry all along. Reading a story like that in a high school classroom isn't easy, and I’m sure plenty of students in my class felt uncomfortable with how dark and painful the subject matter was. Slavery isn't just a distant topic in a textbook, it is heavy, real history that carries real trauma into a room. My point in all this is to point out how ridiculous it seems when I compare what schools routinely keep on the syllabus versus what gets targeted by book bans today. Nobody ever tried to ban "Desiree's Baby" from my high school, even though it contained racial slurs, infanticide, and suicide, and whenever someone brings up challenging books like “To Kill a Mockingbird” people have a complete meltdown defending it because the slurs are “just words” or “part of history.” Yet modern books like New Kid, a graphic novel that deals with the very real weight of microaggressions and trying to fit in at a new school, are constantly being challenged and banned.
ReplyDeleteThat double standard really highlights what book bans are actually doing. Older "classics" are allowed to stay because people treat them as distant history, where as contemporary books like “New Kid” or “The Hate U Give” basically hold a mirror up to show how bias still affects kids in schools today. Looking back, I’m grateful my high school teacher didn't shy away from unfiltered, uncomfortable literature, because those stories forced all of us to sit with the human cost of racism and actually stayed with me to this day. Banning books just to avoid discomfort doesn't us or erase painful history, it just takes away a guided, safe space to learn from it and build real empathy.
** doesn't protect us
ReplyDelete