Tuesday, August 18, 2026

Sept. 2…Crap Detection as a Purpose of School

Postman has some interesting ideas about what kinds of skills we need to learn in school. Looking back, do you think you were ever taught how to “crap detect”? If so, describe the learning experience. If not, why do you think you were never taught to do this? How might this purpose of schooling be particularly relevant in our age of social media?

28 comments:

  1. I think Postman has a good point about how school should teach us to "crap detect". Looking back, I don't think I was ever directly taught how to do this. We learned how to find information and use sources for assignments, but I don't remember being taught how to really question wheather something was true or if someone was just trying to convince us of something. Usually, we were told to find a "reliable source", but not always how to tell what actually makes a source reliable. I think learning how to crap detect is especially important now because of social media. We see much information every day, and anyone can post something and make it look believable. Just because a post has a lot of likes or people sharing it doesn't mean it is true. I think schools should teach students to stop and ask questions like "Who posted this?", "Where did this information come from?" and "Is there evidence to support it?" Social media makes it really easy to believe something without thinking about it, so knowing how to recognize misinformation is an important skill that we should have learned in school.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Irelyn Here- I do not think I was ever directly taught how to “crap detect” in school. I was taught how to find information, memorize facts, and complete assignments, but I was not always taught how to question whether the information itself was accurate or trustworthy, maybe occasionally in terms of detecting bias or finding reliable sources but. Postman’s idea of “crap detecting” is especially important today because of social media. We are constantly exposed to information, advertisements, opinions, trends and news, and it can be difficult to tell what is actually true. People can share false information very quickly, and algorithms can show us content that matches what we already believe. I think “crap detecting” should be considered an important purpose of education because learning is also about how to think critically and decide what information deserves our trust. In the age of social media, this skill is especially important because being educated means being able to navigate an enormous amount of information constantly without automatically believing or sharing everything we see.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey, It's Elizabeth! I don't ever remember being taught how to decipher if something was factual or not. I remember being told that I needed to read an article, make a claim, and then find facts that support the claim. They never told us that we needed to read the article and find things that could be false.I think that I was never taught how to decide whether something was factual or not, because the teachers were following what they knew and no one ever took a minute to figure out if it was helpful for us to teach us the difference.I was most definitely taught about bias and sources but was never taught to question the content that we were learning.I think that not being educated on "crap detecting" is how our generation is less involved because we don't know how to decipher between what's actually real and what's not.Social media doesn't help this either because so many people post things online and many people will say that they agree or believe it without doing any background research. They think that the people who are posting it know what they are talking about and just move on. The truth is you never know if what you are reading is true unless you take the time to do your research on the topics that your interested in.

    ReplyDelete

  4. Dylan here: I was actually taught how to crap-detect in school, especially in History and English classes. We always had to test the credibility of websites we were using, whether articles were primary or secondary sources, etc. When we would pick our own sources, my teachers drilled into our brains to cross-check with other sources to find discrepancies in truthfulness. It is something I really didn’t learn until getting into harder classes in High School, but I believe it should be taught at a much younger age, especially because of how much misinformation/disinformation is on the internet these days. With the rise of AI and other deep-fake sources, it is becoming increasingly more difficult to tell what’s real and what’s not, so teaching upcoming generations how to crap-detect is becoming way more important than ever.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Ki’Anni here
    In a way I do think I was informally taught to “crap detect”. My junior year I took AP Psychology and in one of our units we learned about conformation biases: actively searching for information that favors things you already support, and belief perseverance: sticking to your beliefs even when you’re shown evidence that clearly proves it false. Both of these ideas interested me especially because I'm also very into politics and connected this to how people will only read political articles or news stations that continue to confirm their beliefs even when something is clearly false. I used this knowledge to try and stop myself from only viewing videos or reading articles that confirmed what I already believed. I started to question what I was consuming and check for biases. Many people don’t think to question information they receive and after reading/viewing one thing they believe it’s true and start to spread this misinformation. While crap detection might not need to be a subject in school, I do think it should be integrated into English and History classes, especially because these are classes where you read lots of articles and need to analyze what you’re consuming. It’s important for students to understand how to crap-detect and make educated opinions, especially with social media and the widespread of false information.


    ReplyDelete
  6. Looking back, I don't think I was ever directly taught a formal "crap detector." Instead, it feels like something I learned as I went along through real world experiences of interacting with different people and biases. Over time, I learned to keep an eye out for those who fall under the criteria stated in the passage while also disciplining my own biases so I wouldn't fall into those categories myself. Having a strong crap detector is more important than ever today because of how we consume social media. It is so easy to blindly absorb whatever is placed right in front of us on a screen rather than taking the time to fact-check what we see. Online, information can feel much more believable and persuasive, especially when algorithms are specifically designed to feed us content that aligns with our existing biases. Combined with the tendency to just go along with what the majority thinks, anyone on social media can easily fall into Neil Postman’s categories of fanaticism or inanity. Because the internet makes misinformation so effortless to share and consume, learning to question what we see and check our own biases has become an essential everyday skill.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Personally I don’t think I was ever taught how to decipher whether a text or article was actually factual. How I was taught, it was always just read, agree/disagree and find facts supporting your reasonings. I believe that this not being taught widely in schools is why a lot of people my age just believe anything off the internet if it look “official.”—Karma

    ReplyDelete
  8. Alexis here- to a degree, yes, this is something I learned throughout school, particularly in early middle school when the majority of my work for English class shifted from focus on learning grammar and punctuation rules to writing argumentative and research-based essays. We were taught how to identify reliable sources from biased and untrustworthy ones. This kind of instruction did not apply to many of my other classes, but I was able to use these concepts in other subjects to identify when something I was reading was unfairly targeted, prejudiced, or generally unbelievable.

    ReplyDelete
  9. In school, I was somewhat taught how to “crap detect” when it came to finding sources for essays. Whenever we found a source we wanted to use in our writing, we were taught to see if the author was educated in whatever field they were talking about, if their work was mostly unbiased, and if they used other credible sources within their own work. While it is not exactly the type of “crap detecting” that Postman refers to in his own article, I do believe it was a start in the right direction when it came to determining if the things we see on social media were to be trusted or not. I could definitely see how the purpose of schooling Postman talks about is relevant to this day and age because nowadays social media is overrun with misinformation and we can no longer just believe the first thing that we see. - Christen T.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I think I learned how to crap detect without realizing it during research papers or in english class. In school, I was taught not to believe something right away just because someone said it confidently, there has to be some evidence and reasoning. We were sometimes encouraged to question answers and explain why we thought something was true. I think this is especially important with social media because people can make their opinions sound like facts or not showing the whole story of something. It is easy to believe something when everyone else seems to agree with it. I think schools should teach students to really take in the information and question what they see before believing or sharing it. - Tiffany T

    ReplyDelete
  11. Rowan Donovan - The main way i would say i was taught to "Crap detect" in school was always checking our sources and and making sure the information we used was reliable. I distinctly remember being taught not only to avoid sites like Wikipedia to the best of my ability but to also check the sources of my source. We were always encouraged to seek out first and secondary sources and i distinctly remember having assignments with requirements for these type of sources. However, i do feel that there is a lack in questioning and engaging with what our teachers directly taught us. We weren't always encouraged to engage with the materials that we are taught in college. There where very few classes where this idea of interacting with the material past its face value and those classes where all english AP classes (Advanced Placement). I feel that being able to "crap detect" in our age of social media is very important when it comes to fact checking info especially. Not only that, but being able to interact with these exposures of contradictory news sources in a critical way and exploring past what your shown is very important because if we always just accept what we are told, we would always just accept misinformation and lies.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I was taught a form of “crap detection” in history and English class throughout middle and high school. While flawed, I learned how to detect propaganda and logical fallacies but only in a very surface-level, obvious way; think Soviet Union posters and exaggerated magazine ads. While I think these lessons are important, they aren't very useful in our modern landscape. I think it would've been more useful to teach the inner workings of these tactics and how to recognise them in everyday conversation/ more subtle contexts. I think that this more nuanced form of “bullshit” isn't by and large taught in schools because it is simply too complicated and subjective to fit into tests and curriculum. With the rise of corporations and political figures being omnipresent as well as the advent of AI, the art of “crap detection” is becoming more complex and ever-evolving, making it difficult to create a relevant and comprehensive curriculum

    ReplyDelete
  13. Eva-Nycole here: I think that I was taught crap detection as a child from my mom and from school. In school we were taught to always use credible sources and fact check said sources before using them in an essay or anything. In elementary school we weren't allowed to just google an answer or use wikipedia, we had to actually find an article. Then in middle and high school we were taught how to cite our work with MLA format. Although sometimes it made the essay harder, being able to write off the dome of my head without AI is such an accomplishing feeling. Especially with our current literacy crisis ‘crap detection’ is very important in schools and in basic everyday life.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Maria M
    I think I was taught crap detection back in school very briefly. We were taught to be able to spot any information that may be misleading. For instance, being able to recognize resources that claims to have reliable information but did not. The purpose of this in our day in age is to I guess be able to recognize when social media is feeding us information that isn’t necessarily true, like the saying, “Not everything you see online is true”. Many influencers or even organizations or politicians may even mislead the public eye.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I think I was partially taught crap detection but really only when they wanted to. I was shown how to tell if an article is reliable but it didn’t go much past that. Something Postman said that stuck out to me was that crap detectors are embedded in one’s values system so you must teach someone how to discover their values which I don’t think happens in school or at least my schools. With my high school and middle school it was always debunk what they want you to debunk and believe what they want you to believe there was never any chance or freedom to choose how you think about the materials. At home It was a different situation, my parents always encouraged us to follow our own values and point out what we do and don’t believe is true we were never swayed to one side of anything. I think learning this skill is super important especially with all media being lies a majority of the time. It’s also hard to create your own values and beliefs if you don’t have a crap detector. If you don’t have something in your head telling you something isn’t right or you never learned how to think critically about things it may cause struggles down the road. - Lucy Belyea

    ReplyDelete
  16. Alexa here-
    I was never taught how to crap detect in school, I was given the information and I was told to just use that information to be able to justify my work. I think a lot of what we are taught today is keeping the important facts from us because they don't want us knowing the real truth and asking those deeper questions about it. In high school and even before that I have always felt like my teachers were teaching us something scripted. I never truly felt like the information they were giving us was from their true findings. I think that can show a lot in social media and anywhere because people are afraid that if the truth comes out, they might lose their platform or their job. Social Media is such a big digital footprint and when something is put out there, it's put out there for life. Some people try to hide stuff that could possibly get them in trouble or lose their platform so they have to dull down what they say and how they say it. Social Media creators typically work within a team and their team is basically telling them what to post so they have to abide by those rules or else they won't be allowed to continue to make content and get paid for it.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I was briefly taught on how to crap detect, especially on how to spot false info and wrong answers in quizzes and tests.
    with the rise of AI and misinformation i believe this was taught to us to make us understand what's reality and what's fake so that we don't go out into the world ignorant (even though most people still go out into the world ignorant but i digress). the common phrase "the internet isn't always real" couldn't be more correct, especially in 2026.

    -Cylie Ortiz

    ReplyDelete
  18. Immanol here,
    I was never really taught how to "crap detect" in school and I unfortunately had to learn through simply learning through life. My town is known for being a small town with not much diversity so many bigoted thoughts and opinions were never really hidden. I never really got to hang around people with a similar ethnicity or people who had the same struggles, but when I did, I learned that there was a ton of hidden underlying thoughts and opinions that were really targeted towards making people just feel terrible.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Grace Rasch-
    Though I didn't realize it at the time, certain units in highschool regarding research and finding sources helped me develop my ability to “crap detect”. We received lessons on how to find reliable and relevant sources and techniques to identity and weed out the weaker texts by looking at authors, associations, organizations, bias, and other factors. Getting students to practice this ability could be seen as particularly important in a world dependant on media so they learn the importance of becoming educated on topics important to them. This way they will be suited to develop their own opinions rather than being swayed by the potential misinformation that exists online.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Chloe Here!
    I was always taught in school to make sure my sources were credible and making sure the urls included .org or .gov, since most of the time those were the most credible when dealing with important topics, especially in history. This helped me determine my ability to "crap detect". We were also graded on whether these sources were credible or not and how much information we took from these websites and to compare to double check that the information being received is correct in order to fact check. This is very important due to so much false information being spread out onto the internet especially in these times.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Just as most people said in the blog, as a student, I was never taught systematically how to determine empty talk. To be honest, schools hardly ever teach practical wisdom.
    I do think "crap-detection" is an interesting topic that has rarely been discussed, and we do need such an ability; however, I would have liked it if Postman had dug deeper.
    What Postman did in this article was provide a kind of instruction manual to open up people's minds, pointing them in a direction to go further. That is, if you are expecting to find all the answers in this article, that would not be the case. For instance, Hannah Arendt discussed the banality of evil through a whole book, while Postman mentioned the idea in just one paragraph.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I think I was taught how to “crap detect” in school. In middle school, I would just use any source and not check if it was credible or not. When it came to assignments in high school and finding sources, my teachers were more persistent about me making sure to check the websites to make sure they were from actual news outlets or that the website ended in .gov. After a while, it just became a habit when doing research papers. One thing all my teachers have said was not to trust Wikipedia because it is not a “reliable source”, so I always stayed clear of it.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Xavier Bailey: In my opinion, Postman's idea concerning the role of schools in educating students on how to "crap detect" is very relevant. After analyzing my academic years at high school, I believe I was never directly educated in the area of critical thinking. We were trained to gather information and use sources when writing essays and other academic papers, but we were rarely asked to think about the truthfulness of the information we used or whether we were manipulated. It was often said we needed to find "reliable sources," but we were not taught how to distinguish them from unreliable ones.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Yulissa here,
    Looking back, I don't think I was ever taught how to “crap detect,” as Neil Postman describes it. I learned some critical thinking skills in my english classes, such as checking sources and identifying bias. I usually had to figure out for myself whether something was trustworthy or misleading. I think that this purpose of schooling is important in the age of where social media is most being used, such as now. AI is being harder to differentiate from real life, people find lots of information every day.

    ReplyDelete
  25. I think once I got to high school I started to get taught crap detection. Before that, it was mainly trying to get kids to understand basics and have a good baseline for comprehension, memorization, grammar, etc. I think when you have a group of different kids who don't have the same motivations for being at school, you can't before a certain age urge them to care about "extracurricular" things; it'll fall flat. But I will say the only classes I ever did do crap detection were English classes (naturally). For Gen Ed, I don't think doing crap detection in other classes (exception for humanities like history and other electives similar to english) is a good idea. I think I never got taught crap detection in those classes because it would muddle the curriculum and cause too much confusion about what to take away, and it would take way too much time to genuinely learn science or math in that way. I also think some people (nationally not just my school) didn't take the things we learned in English seriously, because media literacy is very low and I think not fully reading things through or always wanting some form of a TLDR hurts people more than they realize. Crap detection is absolutely needed when using social media, and it's very evident that lots of people, including myself at times, will take something at surface level and not think to look back and question it if it validates their thoughts already or their politics whatever it may be.

    ReplyDelete

August 24…Popculture

  Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring ...