Tuesday, August 18, 2026

October 12…Bulman Revisited

Think back to Bulman’s ideas about Hollywood and high school. If possible, share something that you think he got right and also provide critique of some aspect of his ideas. 

30 comments:

  1. Irelyn here- I think Bulman absolutely nailed how Hollywood uses different school settings to push specific class narratives, especially how suburban school films focus heavily on individual self-discovery and breaking free from conformity. It perfectly explains why movies like The Breakfast Club or Mean Girls care way more about social cliques and personal expression than actual academics. However, a major critique of his framework is that it can be a bit too rigid and deterministic by boxing films strictly into urban, suburban, or private school categories. By focusing so much on geography and class tropes, Bulman sort of overlooks how modern films mix these genres, and he downplays how student agency or systemic issues can exist outside of just the "urban savior" or "suburban rebel" stereotypes.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think Bulman is right about how high school movies often divide students into groups like jocks, nerds, popular kids, and outcasts to dramatize the effect of the movie. These groups make the school seem like everyone has a certain place or role. Hollywood also tends to make these groups more dramatic by showing extreme conflicts between them or making one group seem completely different from another. I think this is one part of high school movies that is not always realistic because students can have different interests and friendships that do not fit into one category. They can also use ideas like the “white savior,” where one person is shown as the person who comes in and fixes everything for others. This is not something we should expect to happen in real life. Bulman’s ideas are useful for understanding these patterns, but I think real high schools are more mixed and complicated than the way Hollywood usually shows them and not as extreme. - Tiffany

    ReplyDelete
  3. Bulman makes a good point that movies and tv influence how people can view high school. Even if their experiences differ from those portrayed on the screen. The movies often focus on the popularity, relationships, stereotypes, and conflicts between teachers and students.People can develop expectations about what high school is supposed to be like because of all the movies they have watched. I think that not everyone interprets movies in the same way. Some people relate to a character, and others realize that the stories are exaggerated. However, I think they can show positive aspects as well, like friendships, growth, teachers who make a difference. I would say that Hollywood shapes our understanding of education, but the influence depends upon the viewer's experiences.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think Bulman got it right when he talks about how Hollywood can influence the way people see high school. Movies and TV shows can make people believe that high school is all about popularity, cliques, relationships, and drama. I think this is true because a lot of shows focus on those things instead of showing what school is actually like for everyone. However, I also think Hollywood sometimes exaggerates these experiences to make the story more interesting. Not every student fits into a certain group, and not everyone has the same high school experience. I think Bulman could have also considered how students’ backgrounds and real life experiences affect how they relate to these movies. Overall, Hollywood can shape our ideas about school, but it doesn't always show the full picture. - Noura

    ReplyDelete

  5. Dylan here: Bulman definitely has a point that the way the media portrays high school can have an influence on people’s perspectives. Hollywood does, obviously, tend to over-dramatize a lot of moments in teen’s lives, which tends to give people (especially younger children watching TV shows based in high school) a false narrative about what it’s really like to be a teenager in modern society. As we’ve spoken about a lot, cliques and the "popular kids vs. social outcasts” arcs in TV and film, along with media that attempts covering heavy subjects, are places to critique that Bulman also correctly identifies.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Maria M
    Based off Bulman’s idea he definitely nailed the savior trope. Where films portray an individual, mostly in a school setting, struggling and a hero aka normally a teacher or adult “saves” the individual from their struggles. However, I think one of Bulman’s idea was that viewers believe what they see on film. I believe that the audience that watches the film doesn’t necessarily believe everything they see but instead absorb and process what they’re seeing. It’s like the saying, “Not everything you see online is true.”

    ReplyDelete
  7. Bulman makes a point about how Hollywood movies portray high school. Movies often show things like popularity or different cliques, and while that is realistic and relatable to an extent, it is also dramatized for the audience. Hollywood tends to focus more on the drama and stereotypes of high school to make movies entertaining. It's important to note that not every student fits into the popular, jock, or nerd cliques, and not everyone experiences high school the same way.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree with Bulman that depending on how shows portray high schools influence how people think about what high school will look like. However, Hollywood does exaggerate the rules of high school depending on the scene. Example, in the first batch of movies we watched the school is seen as dangerous with unmotivated students. Then a “hero” comes in and saves the day. In the second batch of movies the kids are discovering themselves, the students are in their stereotypical friend groups, but by the end they break out of them which exposes their true identity. I don’t think Bulman’s ideas completely relate to real life, because things aren’t as simple as movies.
    -Ki'Anni

    ReplyDelete
  9. Sam-
    I feel like Bulman was right when he said that there was a specific type of plot that movies tend to follow based on the location of the movie. For example, movies that are set in sub-uraban, like mean girls, were about finding oneself and breaking social norms. Whereas in urban settings it follows more of the savior teacher format. However, the one thing I will criticize Bulman for is his lack of talking about how race also plays a factor. This is because there is clearly a pattern in the movies especially in the urban settings where the students are all black even if in real life it wasn't, like in dangerous minds.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Bullman was spot on in his analysis of high school movie genres. The separation between urban, suburban, and private schools and the different tropes associated with these genres was very apparent in the three movies I watched. Bullman's observation of the savior teacher in the urban school, expressive, rebellious individualism in suburban schools, and breaking free from tradition and expectations in elite private schools really hit the nail on the head. An issue in his analysis was his omission of the racial and even gendered overtones in a lot of these films. For instance, I think it is silly to disregard the role of race within a lot of the urban “savior teacher” movies, and the overt white savior complex that sits at its core.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I do agree with Bulman to a certain extent. Hollywood definitely makes thing over the top but shows what people think typical high school and teenagers are like. I can’t speak for everyone but the stuff that was happening in mean girls was not happening at my school. Everyone definitely finds their people but cliques aren’t really a thing anymore so it’s interesting to see movies and shows still play into them. Hollywood makes movies that are entertaining but essentially are spreading false information.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I believe Bulman makes an excellent point about how Hollywood often portrays high school in a way that society believes rather than the actual realistic experience. One thing I think he succeeded in talking about is how movies often exaggerate high school stereotypes. For example, in mean girls the social status of the students affect how they interact with one another, making high school come off as a competition to fit in. On the other hand, it also shows how students perspectives can change as well. So while I do believe Bulman helps explain a common pattern in Hollywood, his ideas do not always account for how movies portray different tropes.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Alexis- Bulman's ideas about how Hollywood portrays high schools and the students within them differently based on their class and the location of the school is very accurate. After watching Dead Poets Society, which features a majority-white cast in a high-class, private high school, after Stand and Deliver, which features mostly Latino students in a lower-class neighborhood/urban school, the differences are very clear. In Dead Poets Society, the students have more agency, are treated better by the writing and the story as a whole, and most of the teachers act as antagonists to the students, with Mr. Keating fulfilling the "savior teacher" trope.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I think Bulman's assessment of how upper middle, suburban, and urban tropes are played out. Urban schools usually are depicted with the one hero and a bunch of chaotic students unfit for society (at the beginning of the movie), suburban kids are given individuality and split into social groups, and elite kids are shown navigating breaking free from or staying complicit with high parental/ institutional expectations. Two things I'd critique Bulman on are under emphasizing race as a factor in how people are portrayed and overestimating the passivity of American audiences, especially younger ones. Race and also gender heavily influence the hero trope, because the issues portrayed are socioeconomic not just class based and he doesn't really speak to that much which he should've. And two, younger audiences especially kinda make memes or mock tropes or caricatures that are ridiculously ignorant or tone deaf, they aren't as likely to be internalized as Bulman makes the tropes out to be.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I think what Bulman said about how adolescents are depicted in high school films is interesting: “Adolescents in these films are expected to transcend the limitations of their communities.” It indicates that they are depicted as “superheroes” without superpowers that do not exist in reality, but still with powers beyond their age and social status. Some of the films are made to encourage, but once the adolescent audience realizes a movie is a movie, and life is life, they just do not have the power to change the world, fight with their parents, or even convince their teachers; there would be a letdown, and even disillusionment.

    ReplyDelete
  16. - Jared
    Bulman made great generalizations about how movies interpret high school in a broad sense. Specifically, his take on the separation between lower class, middle class, and upper class as a defining background for most of the movies. My only gripe with Bulman is how overgeneralized he makes the entirety of it seem. A lot of movies mix these or even completely challenge these stereotypes while keeping it connected to high school. On that subject, I also think the movies that do challenge those stereotypes are the better ones, even aside from being unique, they usually have more story to add to characters and plot lines because they aren’t stuck to that stereotype or generalization.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I do agree with the general idea of Bulmans article, That films about our educational system reflects and reinforces the ideas we have established in these environments. However, I do think Bulman can be narrow minded when it comes to talking about these films. It is true that a lot of films just follow the stereotypes, but i do feel that neglects to talk about the shifts within our schools and the complex nature of films that go against the template laid out by past films. There are many films that break these traditions and want to look at teachers, students, and the school system through different lenses. Bulmans take on these films i find is pessimistic at times and just lumps in those pieces of media into still following the mold and not trying anything new.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I think Bulman was right with how Hollywood and films made schools have an unrealistic viewpoint on high school and how it was very group divided. I think in all the films that we have watched in class it shows how the students and teachers are in two different groups of people. Even though a teacher may come in to help the students be better or help the class as a whole, there is still a battle between students and teachers and how one might have more power than the other. Each film has a specific plot that they like to follow when it comes to schools and how they are portrayed in films. I feel like they don't make it diverse enough to have the audience understand the meaning of the plot. I also feel as though films made around a plot with a school should be more realistic when it comes to some of its goals or climax moments. Not every school is going to have troubled kids, or kids in need of saving and I think that is seen a lot in films in order to make the teacher a savior in that moment.
    -Alexa

    ReplyDelete
  19. I think Hollywood did get right that in high school the students are divided into groups based of appearance and interest. I feel Mean girls shows this best in the cafeteria scene with all the different categories of students at the tables (the plastics, the art geeks, the desperate wannabes, cool Asians, ect.) this is something that feels very accurate in reals school that i feel Hollywood got right (even though it is a little dramatized it that movie.) -Cylie Ortiz

    ReplyDelete
  20. Xavier here- I believe that Bulman was right with the approach that Hollywood has used in making schools having such an unrealistic impression about high schools, which were extremely divided in terms of grouping. I believe that from all the films that we watched in class, it depicts the idea that both students and teachers belong to different sets of individuals, despite the attempts of a teacher coming into schools to improve and develop the students. The students and teachers are in competition with each other at times with who has the upper hand over the other. Each film usually has a unique plot regarding how schools are usually depicted in films. I think that in those films they usually lack diversity in terms of the plot being presented and they do not make their stories clear enough. Film makers should take into consideration the plots with regards to schools and try to keep it realistic because not all schools contain troubled children who would need to be rescued by a teacher.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Chloe Here!
    I think that Bulman was right in how he described how Hollywood will exaggerate and make it seem like schools are much more dramatic than they really are. He proved that Hollywood sets unrealistic standards for schools and can be based solely on stereotypes. This ultimately divides the class, like in Mean Girls, where they are going against each other like a competition. Along with the classic "white savior," which is used multiple times to help save the students. However, I think Bulman's idea is outdated, as now there are more topics than just these types of movies. Nowadays, there are more things that Hollywood can put into movies rather than what has already been done and reused.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I feel like most of Bulman's ideas were pretty accurate, but his argument on how high school films portray class especially stood out to me. In chapter 1, Bulman argued that most high school movies can be divided by class and depending if the school was urban, suburban, or private they also usually reflect some of the same social issues and tropes. For example, Bulman states that films that center around urban schools usually foster a white teacher savior trope where the teacher feels obligated to "save" their marginalized, usually colored, students. The first round of films we watched in class supports Bulman's point. However, I do think Bulman failed to consider movies that flip the script and break out of these stereotypes. The third round of films we watched all somehow broke out of these stereotypes in unique ways that were not defined by Bulman

    ReplyDelete
  23. I think Bulman is correct about high school tropes and how obsessed Hollywood is with putting each person into a category. It really made me wonder at one point that even the kids who don't seem like they fit in are still put into the category of being "weird," so is there really any true individualism here? I think Bulman's ideas are a good way of thinking about things, but then again, I also think there are positive aspects to these movies rather than just how Bulman portrays them. They still show good messages, genuine friendships, growth, and people who actively try to make a difference, no matter if it's unrealistic or not.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Hi Yulissa here,
    I think Bulman was right that Hollywood movies often reflect high school social groups, including cliques, popularity, and the pressure to fit in. I think these movies can help us understand how students experience friendships, relationships, and social status. However, I think he may overexaggerate how accurately movies represent high school for entertainment.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Grace R - Overall I believe Bulman's description of how education is portrayed in Hollywood is largely accurate. He highlights common tropes and stereotypes whether that be the character of the students and/or teachers or the development of teacher/student relationships in film. After watching our first 2 rounds of films, Bulman’s ideas regarding the two common tropes (students finding their out/coming of age and the savior/transformative teacher) held relatively well in films like ferris bueller and dangerous minds. However, I found this division was unable to apply to the more complex films from the 3rd round of films where student teacher relationships were less simple.

    ReplyDelete

August 24…Popculture

  Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring ...