How was student agency depicted in the film you watched? You might describe and react to student agency in the film or compare characters in the film and whether/what kinds of agenda they possess. Feel free to also suggest topics for discussion when we meet to discuss.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
August 24…Popculture
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring ...
-
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring ...
-
Postman has some interesting ideas about what kinds of skills we need to learn in school. Looking back, do you think you were ever taught ho...
-
What other classes have you had in which individualism was discussed? How was it talked about? Is it seen largely as a good thing or a bad t...
Irelyn here- In The Breakfast Club, student agency is found in the quiet ways the characters reclaim their identities from the rigid boxes adults built for them. At first, Vice Principal Vernon holds all the cards and agency, using detention to force them into a silent, submissive mold. But the kids slowly gain that agency back. They physically take over the sterile library, sneaking through the hallways, smoking weed, venting about their parents, and blasting music and in turn they turn a space meant for punishment into a sanctuary where they actually call the shots. This agency peaks with their final, collective essay. By refusing to write individual apologies and instead authoring a single letter signed by "The Breakfast Club," they reject Vernon’s reductionist labels and force the administration to accept them on their own terms. It would be fun to discuss in class themes surrounding how when you're trapped in a broken system, choosing how you define yourself is the ultimate act of rebellion. It would also be fun to discuss opinions about if we think the agency sticks like if this newfound agency actually survives past Saturday. Do they just go back to their regular cliques on Monday, or did this day permanently change them?
ReplyDeleteIn The Breakfast Club, student agency is shown through how each student acts and makes their own decisions, even though they are constantly being judged and controlled by adults. Each character has a different personality and deals with different expectations from their parents, teachers, and peers. For example, Bender is more outspoken and challenges authority, while Claire and Andrew seem more focused on what other people think of them. As they spend more time together, they start opening up and showing who they really are instead of trying to fit into certain stereotypes. I think this shows that students should have a voice and be able to express themselves instead of always being defined by how others see them. One thing I would bring up for discussion is how much control students actually have over their own choices when adults are constantly setting expectations for them.
ReplyDelete- Noura
Clueless - Maria M
ReplyDeleteStudent agency was shown several times throughout the movie. For instance when Cher refused to accept her grade in the class, thus she uses her way of making two of her teachers fall in love in hopes of getting a better grade. Another time is when Cher acts like the adult towards her dad, taking care of him. Tai also achieved true agency when she was finally able to make her own choices without the help of Cher and her friends. I suppose we can discuss about how Cher has the ability to "manipulate" those around her and if one were to do this in real life it would mostly likely not have the same outcome.
The student agency is conveyed through a school skipping that schemed by the male protagonist, Ferris Bueller. However, I think the student agency is over-exaggerated in Ferris Bueller's Day Off. Ferris seems omnipotent: he can “magically” hack into the school’s computer to change his absence times. He is so well known that it seems like the whole city knows him, and the police even call to wish him a speedy recovery. On the contrary, the teachers and the parents in the film are depicted as fools; they just cannot tell Ferris’s trick. As a teacher, Mr. Rooney even trespasses.
ReplyDeleteIn the movie Clueless, student agency is shown through different ways. Cher is very confident and likes to take control of different situations like when she got a C in class and decided to help her teachers fall in love so she could get a better grade. Another example is Tai, at first, she depended heavily on Cher for advice with boys and fashion. Then as the movie progressed, she eventually becomes more confident in herself and starts making her own decisions.
ReplyDeleteIn The Breakfast Club student agency is mixed, however as the show goes on we could definitely say their agency remains in the hands of the students. During the beginning of the movie we can see that the vice principal has the power, telling the students what to do and giving them an essay to complete. The students don’t listen to him and instead they challenge him. As the movie goes on the students continue to take power, and talk about how they ended up in detention. Each student has a different way of showing their agency. We can see Bender as the stereotypical “rebellious” student. He constantly gets in trouble and is disrespectful towards authority figures. On the other hand, the other students aren’t as loud or outspoken for themselves, but by the end of the show they speak up for themselves more. At the end of the show the Brian does the essay for the group, but he brings up the stereotype the vice principal put on them. The essay Brian wrote shows us how students attained agency through explaining themselves instead of allowing the authority figure to do it for them.
ReplyDelete-Ki'Anni
Dylan here: In The Breakfast Club, agency for the four students is depicted through their defiance of the expectations their principal and their parents put on them. The principal sees them all as delinquents with no reason to be respected, insulting the students and threatening them with violence. The different parents also have rigid thoughts and pressures to put the kids under, often being abusive, neglectful, or expecting too much work and dedication out of a teenager. The library and the empty school hallways become a place where they can connect and put differences aside, because they realize they're all way more similar than they appear on the outside. Having no peers or adults to please means they can all interact and work together against higher power without judgement. The ending monologue of the letter they write is especially telling of that, being narrated by John [Bender], who is picked on the most by Principal Vernon and his parents, being deemed the least likely to go anywhere in life. He is able to rise above and essentially become the lead and the character followed throughout the movie the most from beginning to end.
ReplyDeleteThis is Sam. In Mean Girls, student agency is shown through the ways students make their own choices and influence the social environment of their school. Cady initially has a lot of agency because she chooses to change herself and become part of the Plastics in order to understand and expose them. Regina George also demonstrates strong agency because she intentionally controls her friendships, reputation, and social status at school. However, Regina often uses her agency to manipulate and control other students, while Cady eventually realizes that her choices are hurting the people around her. Characters such as Janis and Damian also use their agency by challenging the Plastics and encouraging Cady to stand up against Regina. Overall, the film shows that students have the ability to shape their own identities and social environments, but their choices can have positive or negative consequences.
ReplyDeleteAgency was shown in Mean girls through the choices of the students. In the film, students were separated based on popularity and "classes", which played a big role in how they acted in school. Regina George showed a lot of agency because she was basically the queen of the school and the leader of her group. Everyone would copy Regina George's outfits or her actions. Cady also showed agency too when she wasn't focused on popularity and was comfortable being herself. Once she started hanging out with The plastics, she made the choice to change her appearance and behavior so she could fit in. Even though her friends influenced her, she was still making those choices herself. Later, Cady realized that she had become someone she did not want to be and decided to take responsibility for her actions. - Tiffany
ReplyDeleteStudent agency was depicted in mean girls by showcasing certain characters with an amount of power they hold. Once Cady realized how much power Regina George had on the school she decided to take matters into her own hands by turning her own friends against her. She wanted revenge for realizing that rumors were being spread about her and overall just how fake she really was. Cady was the new girl in school so naturally i think it's realistic to have the new girl get sucked into a mean girl clique. She clearly knew that none of them were truthful people to begin with but when she was being used by other people to get revenge for their past experiences made her turn against her own self and her own truths.
ReplyDelete-Alexa
In Clueless, student agency was depicted through the students seemingly running the school and the teachers and authority figures rarely being shown or being extremely passive. The main character, Cher, had the most agency compared to anyone else in the film. Whether she was in school and at home, Cher regularly used her charm to get what she wanted. Occasionally, her actions did help others, but it was usually just because it served her own agenda. Some possible topics to discuss in class is how realistic the film, Clueless, is to the actual American high school experience and if Cher's decisions throughout the movies were moral.
ReplyDeleteIn Mean Girls, through the ways the students made their choices and influenced the environment around them. Cathy actively changes herself throughout the movie to fit in with Regina and the other students while being influenced by Janice to do this. I believe Regina had the strongest agency in the school and she knew how to use it (even if it was to manipulate others). I think the movie really shows how students can shape their school images into something while also highlighting the obvious peer pressure some undergo to fit in more.—Karma
ReplyDeleteIn The Breakfast Club, agency shifts throughout the movie. At the beginning, the vice principal, Richard Vernon, has all the authority and agency, but by the end, the kids find their own agency, culminating in only writing one essay about how the concept of the essay was stupid to begin with. The film centers around the students' fight for agency and identity while navigating the boxes and categories they were put into by the adults around them as well as each other. They spend the majority of the movie talking about their living situations and how they affected their personal autonomy and identity/ stereotypical cliques they fit into. At its core, much like other “suburban” high school movies, The Breakfast Club is about students fighting for agency and identity.
ReplyDeleteChloe Here!
ReplyDeleteIn Ferris Bueller's Day Off, the show's agency is really mainly conveyed through skipping school, as Ferris fakes being sick to get out of school. Throughout the movie, he goes to great lengths to not be caught, setting up mechanisms for when his parents walk in, hacking into the school system, and even pretending to be family members. This is very unrealistic and would most likely never happen in this day and age. Along with the fact that he seems well known and popular enough for teachers and parents to know what kind of person he is, but they are instead ignorant of what he is doing throughout the movie.
Alexis-- I watched Ferris Bueller, which centers around the main character of Ferris having agency. He skips school, goes to a museum, a baseball game, a parade, and more with his best friend and girlfriend to have a fun day out before they graduate and see much less of each other. Ferris is determined to enjoy life, and finds the obligation of school less serious compared to his sister, who is (until the end of the film) determined to get him caught for skipping class.
ReplyDeleteI think in Ferris Bueller, Farris Bueller is the one who holds agency. He has a whole day of lies and tricks planned out who everyone falls for which is very unrealistic. He skips school and gets his best friend and girlfriend in on it as well it shows he holds a lot of power and is very persuasive. He's also very popular and well liked so everyone just believes what he says instead of questioning it.
ReplyDelete_Lucy
DeleteYulissa here,
ReplyDeleteThe film I watched was Mean Girls. Student agency is shown through how characters make choices while dealing with pressure from their classmates. When Cady is introduced she isn't worried about popularity, but as she becomes part of the Plastics, she changes her behavior to fit in and gain popularity. Regina also shows strong agency because she influences and controls other students. Janis and Damian show agency by refusing to follow the Plastics social rules. I think the movie shows that having agency means more than being powerful or popular, it means being able to make your own choices and to be yourself rather than fitting in. A discussion question would be whether Cady truly regains her agency at the end or simply finds a different way to fit in.
In The Breakfast Club the main characters start off in a pretty bad place. They're forced to be in these very closed off titles that are supposed to limit them and demoralize them. They slowly but surely take those names, and they don't take them that seriously and they make their name their own. They build a sense of camaraderie doing things that teenagers do like smoking, listening to music, or just talking about their problems. I think we should talk about how media like this sort of tells people to try to create relationships in unlikely places. They tell us to try to continue to keep building relationships and to keep being social no matter how stuck you may feel.
ReplyDeleteIn the movie Clueless, student agency really lies in the hands of the students because the entire school environment revolves around them, their popularity, status, and social hierarchy. Adults and teachers almost don’t exist or are super passive, which leaves the students with full control over the school. Cher is the Ideal popular girl who seems to have it all, and she uses her agency to actively shape her world whether that’s negotiating her grades or playing matchmaker for her teachers. Her best friend Dionne shares that same high status, giving them a ton of influence. When they take Tai under their wing, Tai starts out with very little agency, relying entirely on Cher and Dionne to tell her how to dress, act, and who to date. However, as the movie goes on, Tai develops her own sense of agency and starts making her own choices (even standing up to Cher), showing how agency can shift as characters grow.
ReplyDeleteGrace Rasch-
ReplyDeleteStudent agency is depicted in Ferris Bueller‘s Day Off particularly through the characters Cameron and Ferris. Ferris expresses his agency by choosing to skip school and instead, taking control of his own day. By acting sick and gaining the support of his peers he is able to overcome the principle’s attempts to catch and punish him. While at first Cameron, mostly acts under the agency of his father, Ferris uses his I influence to get Cameron to be more adventurous. I believe Cameron has the largest arc in terms of agency as he shifts from being completely dominated by the opinions of his father to realizing the power he can hold over his own life if he chooses to.
In Mean Girls, student agency is depicted as almost natural and laidback but controlling. It's understood that these are teens, and by default they are chaotic and messy, but the adult agency isn't a match for what the students are able to do. Regina George builds her agency through social manipulation and has strict rules, and a Burn Book to dictate how others (in her high school/ life) can act and dress. Cady first uses her agency to infiltrate the Plastics, but she eventually gets stuck in Regina's system very fast. Cady's friends Janis and Damian exercise their agency by remaining hard on resistance and rejecting Regina (dominant social norms) and doing their own thing. In a weird way, the movie does a good job at showing how easy it is to get sucked into systems of power and what happens to those who resist it while still being a "teen" movie.
ReplyDelete- Taylor
In clueless the students run the film Cher is the leader and ruler of her own little world she does what she wants when she wants and doesn't ever take no for an answer. the world essentially revolves around theses highschoolers. - cylie ortiz
ReplyDeleteIn the film Ferris Buellers Day Off, Agency is show through our main character Ferris, but also his friends and teachers in the film. Ferris is the character that displays the most use of agency, and throughout the film he convinces his girlfriend Sloane, and best friend Cam, to use their agency and take control of their lives. Ferris is a full believer that you control your own life, and you have to seize it despite what others may say. His Agency is challenged by his sister and principle, who use their agency to try and stop ferris and make him face consequences for his actions. This results in those characters facing karma, while ferris gets off scotts free at the end. It's important to note that this movie isn't a rejection of school, but a rejection of school taking away students agency when it comes to what they learn and how they spend their time.
ReplyDeleteXavier here-I would say that The Breakfast Club demonstrates how students' struggles to be themselves when society and adults place them into different categories. At first, the students are characterized as stereotypical types, and Mr. Vernon attempts to dictate them their behavior but he does not know what they experience beyond school walls. When spending more time together, they become more open and start shaping their own identities, not letting other people dictate them how to behave. The importance of the final group essay lies in the fact that it is a collective product instead of an individual one dictated by the school.
ReplyDelete