Tuesday, August 18, 2026

September 28…Critical Film Viewing

Share something about the film you watched that you hope to discuss in class. Reply to the comments that name your film so that all of the comments for each film are grouped together. Try to include something from what we have discussed so far in this course (e.g, purposes of school, individualism, opportunity, class and race, teacher and/or student agency, the limits of the art form, etc.). 

27 comments:

  1. Elizabeth here - I thought that at the beginning of the movie it depicts a school with low expectations, violence, and a heavily dominated student agency. The new principle believed that he could make a difference and change the schools culture of violence, drugs, and racism rather than watch the kids walk all over everyone. Joe Clark saw something in the kids that they did not see and he did everything he could to change the culture of their school. This movie depicted what public schools should be doing in trying to help their students because they care rather than just getting a paycheck.

    ReplyDelete
  2. One thing I hope we talk about from Lean on Me is how the movie shows the purpose of school and what it means to give students opportunities. I noticed that the students were dealing with a lot of challenges, and it made me think about how things like race and class can affect a student’s education. I also thought it was interesting how Mr. Clark used a very strict leadership style because he believed it would help the students succeed. I would like to talk about whether his approach actually gave students more opportunities or if there were better ways to support them. - Noura

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. irelyn here- Mr. Clark used highly untraditional teaching methods that, while often frowned upon, ultimately changed the trajectory of Eastside High and the lives of his students. I think we should analyze the themes depicted in Lean on Me, such as race, gang violence, drug dealing, and the systemic neglect of inner-city schools. The film fits perfectly into the popular tropes of this era like the savior educator who arrives to reform a troubled school and push troubled at-risk youth to realize their true potential. Mr. Clark exercises absolute agency through an aggressive, top-down leadership style. His assertiveness is unyielding, whether he is firing complacent staff, or demanding discipline from the student body. I think it would be fun to talk about how he forced immediate structural and cultural shifts within the school. I freaking loved the film!

      Delete
  3. Dylan here: After watching Dangerous Minds, I would like to discuss how this movie follows the stereotypical “teacher as a savior” trope we’ve been discussing in class, along with how it handles much darker and very real topics outside the classroom setting. It follows the format we’ve seen many times: A new wide-eyed teacher comes in, has to figure out how to gain the students’ trust, gets into some trouble for her unorthodox methods of teaching, and ultimately gets taught a large lesson by the students by the end of the movie. However, this film also follows Louanne (the teacher) to the homes and personal lives of a few of her students, realizing just how much their school and environments have failed them. Two of her students are pulled out of school by their mother because she thinks what they are learning in school is a waste and that their future is about “paying bills” and not “becoming doctors or lawyers” (being realistic vs. encouraging them to follow their dreams and goals). Another one of her students is pregnant and is encouraged heavily by the school to leave, and another student ends up losing his life by the end of the film. Overall, I thought this movie got rid of many of the “cornier” aspects and did a really nice job making the chemistry between characters natural, as well as pulling on heartstrings.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. After watching dangerous minds I feel it would be good to talk about how the teacher hero trope was played. More interestingly, however, I feel like it's important that the movie didn't have everything going right and everyone was happy. It shows that even though the teacher was good and the students trusted her the school system and environment failed them. I feel like this is a little different from welcome back Mr. Kotter and blackboard jungle where the whole time it was the kids that were being bad and the story concludes with the kids trusting the teacher. I would say this is a little more similar to Abbbott Elementary that focuses more on the system and polices than the kids.

      Delete
    2. After watching Dangerous Minds, I hope to discuss the music choices of the film and how they choose to portray race and class. I noticed that whenever a scene was highlighting just the students, hip-hop and rap music came on. While this may have just been to reflect what teenagers were listening to at the time, I also think this choice was much more intentional to show that the students were "violent" and "troubled", something rap and hip-hop music has also been mischaracterized to be. This kind of goes into what we have been talking about in class with the white savior troupe where the teacher is trying to transform the lives of low-income, inner-city students of color who are seen as a lost cause to the rest of the administration.

      Delete
    3. Chloe Here!
      While watching Dangerous Minds, I found it interesting how, even though the students looked up to the teacher and saw her as their "Light", not everything went right. I think it was very stereotypical for most of the students to be from broken households or poor upbringings, and it shows the teacher as some kind of "savior" for the students. Though I liked that, even though it showed a lot of stereotypes we've talked about in class, it also showed how the school system had failed the students, which is different from other movies where it's more the teachers fault or the students. I liked that it shed light on school system problems.

      Delete
    4. After watching Dangerous Minds, I would like to discuss how the school system failed the students. They hired Ms. Johnson to teach this "troubled" class but didn't like the way she was getting them engaged in the class topics because it didn't follow the curriculum. Towards the end, Emilio came to Principal Grandey to tell him about Shorty being on drugs, but because Emilio didn't knock, the principal immediately dismissed him and sent him away, which ultimately contributed to Emilio's death. The school system stereotyped these kids the moment they walked through the school doors, they didn't try to help them because in their minds, they knew where these kids would end up.

      Delete
    5. Gracie Rasch-
      After watch dangerous minds I felt the movie had both weaknesses and strengths as it portrayed the education system. The movie emphasized the importance of choice, seeming to push that the purpose of schooling and education was to give student more choice over their own future. In this movie there are a fair amount of stereotypes regarding rage and class and the teacher, Ms. Johnson takes on a very involved role in her students lives, introducing a bit of a “savior” complex or dynamic. The death of her student Emilio addresses the way in which the education system looks over struggling students.

      Delete
    6. Dangerous Minds looks like an average savior movie that has the teacher coming in trying to help the students on anyway she can, except its not. Dangerous Minds definitely had some Hollywood glamour in there but it kind of strays a bit from the savior trope. The main character doesn't really go into this thinking that she can just change them due to her impeccable skills of communication, she gives up and she also has problems of her own. She can be seen as being just as fragile as the kids in some spots of the movie, such as when she says that she had also gone through her getting abused by her husband or where she straight up tells the kids that the job just made her sad. Of course, she comes back in the end, but they do play it up a bit and give her more relatability than someone whose just calm and collected the whole time.

      Delete
  4. When watching the movie freedom writers I felt very moved by how the teacher was able to make the kids come together and realize that they each were struggling with their own issues and they would go against each other because of it. They were scared to speak up about what has been happening because they would be scared of judgement or violence. I think the setting within the classroom and how the teacher was able to handle it says a lot about how she is as a teacher and how she came into this school knowing what has been happening and still tried to find light out of the situation. No matter what race the student was in the class, they all had something against them or a bad lifestyle back home. One of the students mentioned that she hates white people because she has only seen the bad in them. The teacher does fun activities for the kids to help them feel more comfortable in the classroom as well as with each other. They are able to come to a sense of agreement that no one has it easier than someone else. They are able to learn from one another and even though we dont see much English being taught, at least there is still a lesson being made in the film and showcasing how it affects others. -Alexa

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Freedom Writers

      While watching the film, I felt the change in the students was too great, which was almost unreal; however, when I realized the film was based on a true story, it became compelling. I like how the teacher and the students learn from each other: as a white person, Ms.G was not understanding her students’ situation enough at the beginning, and the students were being aggressive to her simply because she was white.

      Delete
    2. Freedom Writers: The film follows a dedicated first-year English teacher who inspires a racially divided, at-risk class of high school students in Long Beach, California, to overcome gang violence, prejudice, and low expectations through writing and tolerance. I feel that this film has an interesting way of depicting the relationships between teachers and their students, and how teachers can learn from their students as well. She sees the prejudice that her students face and chooses to understand them while also teaching them to understand each other. She strives to give them a space where they can feel heard. I do feel that this film falls into a blurred line when it comes to leaning into a white savior trope. At the same time, I think the film strives to address why these students are facing these issues, rather than brushing them off as something they have to deal with because of their race. It shows the teacher understanding that it is not simply the students against each other or the teachers against the students, but also the administration and school system working against underprivileged students. I think this raises an interesting question about the purpose of school and how much change a teacher can actually create within a system that is already failing its students.

      Delete
    3. Lucy: After watching freedom writers I was reminded of our conversation about the white savior complex and it made me wonder what this movie would have looked like if the kids she was teaching were a different race. If they were also white would she have still cared as much, did she even care about the kids or did she just want to feel good about herself and boost her ego. I think if you look at this movie from the view of 2026 you get a very different perspective than if you watched it when it came out. As our society changes, it is reflected in the films and culture we produce. This film is a great example of how the white savior complex was not commonly accepted in society and being the "white savior" was seen as positive and uplifting thing.

      Delete
  5. After watching the film Freedom Writers, It made me feel a sense of empathy for the students and what they were going through. In the beginning of the movie, it showed what the student went through and how much they had to overcome just to be alive. They dealt with violence, racism, gangs, and problems at home which made it harder for them to focus/care on school. Seeing the improvement in the students throughout the movie gave not only the teacher hope but the students themselves. The teacher never once gave up on them and did everything she could just to help them succeed. She believed in them even when other teachers didn't. This comes to show the purpose of school and how the teacher can make a difference in the students life and changed them. -Tiffany

    ReplyDelete
  6. Maria M - To Sir, With Love

    I'll be honest it was really difficult to watch this film since I am not a big fan of slow paced movies. However, after watching this film it is the typical teacher learns from students and vice versa. The students were able to teach Thackeray that his purpose wasn't just to have an engineering position, but to shape other lives, making him reject the offer of an engineering position, leading to him staying at the school. I think agency was shown when Thackeray realized that he needed to set standards for the students and the students also realized that they come to terms with Thackeray. For instance, during the boxing scene he was able to prove he can defend himself but does not lose his temper, and teaches them that controlling oneself is key. One thing I do want to talk about was one of the beginning scenes when Thackeray entered the classroom filled with smoke and made the boys leave and girls stay. I'm not sure if I missed the scene or was just confused, but I am wondering what was inside the furnace that made him slutshame the ladies. In the end, he was able to build a relationship with his students by treating them sort of like equals.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. eva-nycole here w/ To Sir, with love
      At first, it was hard to watch this movie because of its ‘old-timey’ feel; I assumed it would portray the main Black character as a stereotype. In the first scene of Mr.Thakery meeting his coworkers, he called him a ‘black sheep,’ whether that’s because he’s simply new to the school or because he is the only black teacher. But the movie did grow on me a bit. The other new teacher, Julian, says that the school is challenging and frightening, and has no form of punishment. I did find that pretty unusual, because it almost defeats the purpose of school. Not to say the purpose of school isn’t to be punished, but having some form of punishment or consequence in place helps to motivate kids to not fail.

      Delete
  7. Stand and Deliver, Mr. Escalante teaches AP calculus to underprivileged Hispanic students at Garfield High School. He pitches his idea of AP calculus to his students as a means for social mobility. This theme is present throughout the movie and shows education as a means for upward mobility while also highlighting systemic inequalities. The students at Garfield High were expected to not be smart enough to pass the AP test, but when Mr. Escalante met them where they were at and all passed the test, they were immediately accused of cheating. I think at its core, this movie calls into question the concept of public schooling being a “great equalizer"; even after they did everything right, they were still accused of wrongdoing and had to prove their innocence.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Alexis here- along those lines, something I found interesting about this film is that it shows the consequences of Mr. Escalante's teaching style throughout the film. His character has some aspects of the "savior teacher" trope, especially when it comes to his no-nonsense attitude towards Angel and others who are late. However, this results in several of the students disliking him (at the beginning and in the middle), since they all have other issues going on in their lives that are not related to his class.

      Delete
    2. Jared - Mr. Escalante absolutely embodies the "savior" teacher trope, but outside of that, there were unique things about him. He had to become comfortable with the students over time to be able to teach them correctly and went through hardships doing so. I also think the way he taught was interesting and very funny. Even though the savior trope is prevalent, a story that sets a clear goal for marginalized people is always worth a watch.

      Delete
    3. Taylor - I agree, while the cheating allegation was 100% prejudiced, it's good that they included that; oftentimes in "diverse/urban" or lower-income schools, students can work exceptionally hard and still return with nothing. And usually these types of movies ignore the fact that systemic racism is actually systemic. We even talked about in class how not succeeding is seen as a individual weight and a moral failure and not actually seen as a genuine systemic issue that can't in 2 hours be solved with a hero teacher that wants to save a group of kids victim to certain institutions.

      Delete
  8. Stand and Deliver - I think an interesting thing about the movie is that it didn't do the typical life lesson with a side of being able to miraculously read at the end. Part of that is probably because it was based on Escalante genuinely teaching students Calc in real life, but still the teacher did a good job of not completely pandering to the students. While it still had some cliche stuff like the hero teacher stepping into the student's personal life (Escalante scolding a student's dad for not wanting his daughter to go to college), it was mostly filled with actual ways to teach the students about a particular subject. I think oftentimes with films like these, the movie ends up being a life/ humanity lesson and ignores completely the fact that they're supposed to be in school and learning, and that the whole job of the teacher is to teach whatever subject they're being paid to do. And Escalante did a good job of balancing the humanity with the actual subject lesson in this movie I think.- Taylor

    ReplyDelete
  9. Yulissa here,
    The movie I watched was To Sir, with Love. Honestly I eeny meeny miny moed the movie options and this movie was the winner. I like the setting of the story and where it takes place, london post world war II. I wouldn't have watched this movie if it weren't for this class but i'm glad I did because it has shown me that a lot of school related movies have a similar plot throughout the years.Thackeray shows that he is overqualified for this job and expresses how he doesn't want to do it, however he is racially marginalized by the larger society. Showing his temper would invite racialized condemnation.

    ReplyDelete
  10. One aspect of the movie Lean on Me I wanted to unpack was how Joe Clark’s strict leadership highlights the tension between authority and student agency, as well as the broader purposes of school. In the film, Clark uses an aggressive approach like chaining school doors shut, expelling dozens of students, and treating standardized test scores and order as the ultimate goals. While the movie frames this as tough love to save Eastside High, it kind of raises another question on whether his methods actually give students more opportunity or just replace system neglect with heavy control. The film uses a "hero educator" storyline. Which in a way mistakenly frames massive problems, like underfunding, racism, and class divides as personal failures that one person can solve.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Freedom Writers is very big on the "White Savior" complex that we discussed in class with all the kids she was teaching being people of color. The thing that stuck out to me the most and why i picked Freedom Writers is that the teacher was a woman rather then the man which is also a common trope in class that woman make up most of the population of teachers but men are still portrayed more as teachers than woman are. -Cylie Ortiz

    ReplyDelete
  12. Xavier here- I would say that Stand and Deliver portrays well the significance as well as the limits of education as a method to attain social mobility. Mr. Escalante has the qualities of the “savior teacher,” but I find it intriguing the way he must develop personal relationships with his students in order to connect with them. On the other hand, the charges against the students for cheating portray how even when disadvantaged students try to do well, they may be discriminated against and have to prove themselves. The connection can be made to our discussion of how educational failure is usually perceived as an individual failure despite the fact that there are bigger issues that are not taken into consideration.

    ReplyDelete

August 24…Popculture

  Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring ...